You appear to have a personal bias against Mr. Raymond that isn't instructive. Your points about Seth Klaman were. Somehow I think the analysis that went into his buying 7.1 million shares at much higher prices and recently selling them trumps the sophmoric responses you got. If he's wrong and they are right, maybe one or both of them should claim to be the best investor in modern times, a title many are now putting on Klaman. He's not infalible, but you should have a particularly strong conviction to swim in the opposite direction he is swimming in.